Conceptual Based Notes
Chapter : Nationalism In Europe
Frédéric Sorrieu: The Dream of Worldwide Democratic and Social Republics (1848)
- In 1848, Frédéric Sorrieu, a French artist, prepared a series of four prints.
- These prints visualized his dream of a world made up of democratic and social republics.
- In his print, Sorrieu shows the peoples of Europe and America—men and women of all ages and social classes—marching together in a long procession.
- In his vision, the peoples of the world are grouped as distinct nations, each identified by its national flag and traditional costume.
- The people are shown offering homage to the Statue of Liberty.
- Liberty is personified as a female figure, as was common during the French Revolution.
- She carries the torch of Enlightenment in one hand, symbolising freedom and reason.
- In her other hand, she holds the Charter of the Rights of Man, representing equality and civil rights.
- In the foreground of the picture lie the broken remains of symbols of absolutist institutions.
- These broken symbols represent the end of monarchy and oppression.
- Above the scene, Christ, saints, and angels symbolise fraternity and brotherhood among the nations of the world.
- The United States and Switzerland lead the procession as they were already nation-states.
- France follows, which is identified by the revolutionary tricolour flag.
- The people of Germany come next, carrying the black, red, and gold flag.
- At that time, Germany was not a unified nation.
- The German flag Symbolised the liberal hopes of uniting German-speaking states under a democratic constitution.
- The procession is followed by the peoples of Austria, the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies, Lombardy, Poland, England, Ireland, Hungary, and Russia
Expected and PY Questions
- Explain Frédéric Sorrieu’s dream in the context of democratic and social republics in France during 1848
- Examine the significance of the Statue of Liberty in Frédéric Sorrieu’s paintings “The dream of worldwide democratic and socialist republics.”
- Analyse the theme of Frédéric Sorrieu’s paintings. How has the French artist visualised in his first print of series of four prints his dream of a world made up of “democratic and social republics”?–
- Why did Frédéric Sorrieu prepare a series of prints on democratic and social republic
French philosopher Ernst Renan (1823-92): What makes a nation?
- A nation is the culmination of a long past of endeavors, sacrifice and devotion.
- A heroic past, great men, glory, that is the social capital upon which one bases a national idea.
- To have common glories in the past,
- to have a common will in the present,
- to have performed great deeds together,
- A nation is therefore a large-scale solidarity …
- Its existence is a daily plebiscite …
- The existence of nations is a good thing, a necessity even.
- Their existence is a guarantee of liberty, which would be lost if the world had only one law and only one master
Modern States and Nation States
Modern state,
A centralised power exercised sovereign control over a clearly defined territory, had been developing over a long period of time in Europe.
Nation state
It was one in which the majority of its citizens, and not only its rulers, came to develop a sense of common identity and shared history or descent.
The French Revolution and the Idea of the Nation
- The first clear expression of nationalism came with the French Revolution in 1789.
- The French Revolution brought important political and constitutional changes.
- Sovereignty was transferred from the monarchy to the body of French citizens.
- The revolution declared that the people would constitute the nation and shape its destiny.
- The revolutionaries introduced measures to create a sense of collective identity among the French people.
- The ideas of la patrie (the fatherland) and le citoyen (the citizen) were promoted.
- These ideas emphasised a united community enjoying equal rights under a constitution.
- The tricolour flag was chosen to replace the royal standard.
- The Estates General was elected by active citizens and renamed the National Assembly.
- New hymns were composed, oaths were taken, and martyrs were commemorated in the name of the nation.
- A centralised administrative system was established.
- Uniform laws were made for all citizens within the territory.
- Internal customs duties and dues were abolished.
- A uniform system of weights and measures was introduced.
- Regional dialects were discouraged.
- French, as spoken and written in Paris, became the common language of the nation.
Expected and PY Questions
- “The French Revolution laid the foundation of nationalism in France.” Explain.
- Analyse the political and administrative changes introduced after the French Revolution.
- Describe the steps taken by the French revolutionaries to create a sense of collective identity among the French people.
- How did the French Revolution strengthen the idea of a nation-state? Explain.
Civil Code of 1804 Or Napoleonic Code
- In the territories under his control, Napoleon introduced reforms similar to those in France.
- Though he restored monarchy and ended democracy, he retained revolutionary principles in administration.
- The Civil Code of 1804, also known as the Napoleonic Code, was introduced.
- It abolished privileges based on birth.
- It established equality before the law.
- It secured the right to property.
- The Napoleonic Code was implemented in regions under French control.
- In the Dutch Republic, Switzerland, Italy, and Germany, administrative divisions were simplified.
- The feudal system was abolished.
- Peasants were freed from serfdom and manorial dues.
- Guild restrictions were removed in towns.
- Transport and communication systems wre improved.
- Peasants, artisans, workers, and new businessmen gained new freedom.
- Businessmen and small-scale producers benefited from uniform laws.
- Standardised weights and measures were introduced.
- A common national currency facilitated trade.
- Movement and exchange of goods and capital between regions became easier.
Draw backs of Napolean
- People realised that new administrative reforms did not provide political freedom.
- There was increased taxation.
- Censorship was imposed.
- Forced conscription into the French army was introduced.
- The burdens of French rule outweighed the benefits of reforms.
Expected and PY Questions
- “Napoleon was both a destroyer and a reformer.” Explain.
- Analyse the impact of the Napoleonic Code on Europe.
- Describe the reforms introduced by Napoleon in the territories under his control.
- How did Napoleon help in spreading the ideas of the French Revolution outside France?
- “The reaction to French rule in the conquered territories was mixed.” Explain.
- Analyse the causes of growing hostility against Napoleon in Europe.
- Why did the advantages of administrative reforms fail to win long-term support for Napoleon?
Political Situation of Europe before the Rise of Nationalism
- Germany, Italy and Switzerland were not unified countries; they were divided into kingdoms, duchies and cantons with separate rulers.
- Eastern and Central Europe were ruled by autocratic monarchs, and people were loyal to the ruler rather than to a nation.
- People did not share a common identity, language or culture, and belonged to different ethnic groups.
- The Habsburg Empire was a multi-national state including regions like Tyrol, Austria, Bohemia, Lombardy, Venetia and Hungary.
- It had diverse groups such as Magyars, Poles, Bohemians, Slovaks, Slovenes, Croats and Roumans.
- Due to this diversity, political unity was weak, and the only common link was loyalty to the emperor.
Expected and PY Questions
- Explain the political and cultural diversity of Europe before the rise of nationalism.
- “The Habsburg Empire was a patchwork of many different regions and peoples.” Justify the statement.
- How did the absence of a common identity affect the growth of nationalism in Europe?
Difference between Aristocrats, Peasants and Middle Class.
| Aristocrats | Peasants | Middle Class |
|---|---|---|
| They were the dominant class and socially powerful. | They were the weakest and largest class. | They were an emerging social group. |
| They were politically powerful. | They were politically weak with little rights. | They were gaining political influence. |
| They were small in number. | They formed the majority of the population. | Their number was moderate and increasing. |
| They owned large estates and town-houses. | They worked as tenants, small owners or serfs. | They worked in trade, industry and professions. |
| They lived luxurious lives. | They lived simple rural lives. | They lived comfortable urban lives. |
| They were united by a common way of life across regions. | Their life was based on agriculture and local customs. | Their life was based on education, trade and business. |
| They spoke French for diplomacy and high society. | They spoke local regional languages. | They spoke national/local languages for business and education. |
| Their families were connected by marriage ties. | Marriage was mostly within village or community. | Marriage was mostly within educated or business families. |
| They supported monarchy and traditional privileges. | They had little political awareness. | They supported liberalism and national unity. |
Expected and PY Questions
- How did the growth of industrialisation lead to the rise of nationalism?
- Explain the social structure of Europe before the rise of nationalism.
- Why did nationalist ideas gain popularity among the educated middle class?
- Describe the pattern of landholding in Western and Eastern Europe.
Different notions of Liberalism
- Ideas of national unity in early-nineteenth-century Europe were closely allied to the ideology of liberalism.
- The term ‘liberalism’ derives from the Latin root liber, meaning free.
For Middle classes
- Freedom for the individual
- Equality of all before the law.
Politically
- The concept of government by consent.
Since the French Revolution, it stood for
- The end of autocracy
- Abolition of clerical privileges
- Framing the constitution
- Representative government through parliament.
Economically
- Freedom of markets
- Abolition of trade barriers
Liberalism and Suffrage
- Equality before law did not mean universal suffrage.
- In revolutionary France, only property-owning men had voting rights.
- Women and non-propertied men were excluded.
- Jacobins briefly granted suffrage to all adult males.
- The Napoleonic Code restored limited suffrage and reduced women’s status.
- Women and poor men later demanded equal political rights.
Expected and PY Questions
- What did Liberal Nationalism stand for? Explain any five points.
- Describe the political, social and economic ideas of liberal nationalism.
- How did liberalism differ from conservative ideology?
- Explain the concept of freedom and equality as understood by liberals.
- Why did women and non-propertied men not have political rights under liberalism?
Economic Obstacles in the German Confederation before 1834
- After Napoleon’s reorganisation, the German region consisted of a confederation of 39 states instead of numerous tiny principalities.
- Each state had its own currency, weights and measures, creating economic confusion.
- A merchant travelling from Hamburg to Nuremberg (1833) had to cross 11 customs barriers.
- Around 5% customs duty was charged at each barrier, increasing the cost of goods.
- The unit of cloth measurement, “elle,” varied: Frankfurt – 54.7 cm, Mainz – 55.1 cm, Nuremberg – 65.6 cm, Freiburg – 53.5 cm
- Different systems of measurement led to time-consuming calculations and trade difficulties.
- These conditions were seen as obstacles to economic growth and free trade.
- The new commercial and industrial classes demanded a unified economic territory with free movement of goods, people, and capital.
- In 1834, a customs union called the Zollverein was formed under the leadership of Prussia.
- The Zollverein abolished internal tariff barriers among member states.
- It reduced the number of currencies from over thirty to two, simplifying trade.
- Development of a railway network improved mobility and strengthened economic integration.
- Economic unity encouraged economic nationalism, which supported the larger movement for German national unification.
Expected and PY Questions
- Examine the role of the Zollverein in strengthening the process of German unification.
- “Economic interests strengthened nationalist sentiments in Germany.” Justify the statement with suitable examples.
Rise of Conservatism after the Defeat of Napoleon (1815)
- After the defeat of Napoleon Bonaparte in 1815, European governments adopted a policy of conservatism.
- Conservatives believed in preserving traditional institutions such as monarchy, Church, social hierarchy, property, and family.
- They did not completely reject modernisation; instead, they felt that modern reforms could strengthen monarchy and state power.
- Measures like a modern army, efficient bureaucracy, dynamic economy, and abolition of feudalism and serfdom were seen as tools to strengthen autocratic rule.
Congress of Vienna and the Reorganisation of Europe (1815)
- In 1815, major European powers – Britain, Russia, Prussia, and Austria – met at Vienna.
- The meeting is known as the Congress of Vienna.
- The Congress was hosted by Austrian Chancellor Klemens von Metternich.
- The Treaty of Vienna aimed to undo the changes made during the Napoleonic Wars.
- The Bourbon dynasty was restored to power in France.
- France lost the territories it had annexed under Napoleon.
- Buffer states were created around France to prevent future expansion:
- The Kingdom of the Netherlands (including Belgium) was set up in the north.
- Genoa was added to Piedmont in the south.
- Prussia received new territories on its western frontiers.
- Austria was given control of northern Italy.
- Russia received part of Poland, and Prussia got a portion of Saxony.
- The German Confederation of 39 states remained unchanged.
Conservative Regimes and Suppression of Liberal Ideas
- The main objectives conservatives regime was to restore monarchies and establish a conservative political order in Europe.
- Conservative regimes were autocratic and did not tolerate criticism or dissent.
- They imposed censorship laws on newspapers, books, plays, and songs.
- Ideas of liberty and freedom associated with the French Revolution were suppressed.
- Despite repression, the memory of the French Revolution inspired liberals and liberal-nationalists.
- One major demand of liberals was freedom of the press.
Expected and PY Questions
- Examine the role of the Congress of Vienna in restoring conservative order in Europe.
- “The conservative regimes set up in 1815 were autocratic.” Justify the statement with suitable examples.
- How did the Congress of Vienna reshape the political map of Europe?
Growth of Revolutionary Secret Societies in Europe after 1815
- After 1815, liberal-nationalists were forced to go underground due to fear of repression by conservative regimes.
- Many secret societies were formed across Europe to train revolutionaries and spread nationalist ideas.
- Being a revolutionary meant opposing the monarchical order established after the Congress of Vienna.
- Revolutionaries aimed to achieve liberty, freedom, and nation-states.
- Giuseppe Mazzini was a prominent Italian Revolutionary.
- Mazzini was born in Genoa in 1805.
- He became a member of the secret society called the Carbonari.
- In 1831, at the age of 24, he was sent into exile for attempting a revolution in Liguria.
- He founded Young Italy in Marseilles to promote Italian unification.
- Later, he founded Young Europe in Berne.
- Members of Young Europe included young revolutionaries from Poland, France, Italy, and the German states.
- Mazzini believed that nations were the natural units of mankind, as intended by God.
- He argued that Italy could not continue to be a patchwork of small states and kingdoms.
- He wanted Italy to become a single unified democratic republic.
- He believed unification was essential for achieving Italian liberty.
- Inspired by Mazzini, secret societies were also established in Germany, France, Switzerland, and Poland.
- His strong opposition to monarchy and advocacy of democratic republics alarmed conservatives.
- Austrian Chancellor Klemens von Metternich described Mazzini as “the most dangerous enemy of our social order.”
Expected and PY Questions
- Examine the contribution of Giuseppe Mazzini to the process of Italian unification.
- “Secret societies played a significant role in the growth of nationalism in Europe.” Justify the statement.
- How did revolutionary nationalism challenge the conservative order established in 1815?
The July Revolution of 1830 (France)
- First major uprising took place in France in July 1830.
- The Bourbon kings (restored after 1815) were overthrown.
- Liberal revolutionaries established a constitutional monarchy.
- Louis Philippe became the new king.
- Metternich remarked: “When France sneezes, the rest of Europe catches cold.”
- The revolution inspired other movements across Europe.
Belgium’s Independence (1830)
- The July Revolution influenced an uprising in Brussels.
- Belgium broke away from the United Kingdom of the Netherlands.
- Belgium became an independent nation.
Greek War of Independence (1821–1832)
- Greece had been under Ottoman Empire rule since the 15th century.
- The struggle for independence began in 1821 by the inspiration of revolutionary nationalism in Europe.
- Nationalists in Greece got support from other Greeks living in exile and also from many West Europeans who had sympathies for ancient Greek culture.
- Poets and artists lauded Greece as the cradle of European civilisation
- They mobilised public opinion to support its struggle against a Muslim empire.
- The English poet Lord Byron organised funds and later went to fight in the war, where he died of fever in 1824.
- The Treaty of Constantinople (1832) officially recognised Greece as an independent nation.
Role of Language in Polish Nationalism (Rebellion of 1831)
- Language played an important role in developing nationalist sentiments.
- After Russian occupation of Poland, the Polish language was removed from schools.
- Russian language was imposed everywhere to suppress Polish identity.
- In 1831, an armed rebellion took place against Russian rule, but it was crushed.
- After the rebellion failed, members of the Polish clergy used language as a tool of resistance.
- Polish was used in Church gatherings and religious instruction.
- Many priests and bishops who refused to preach in Russian were jailed or sent to Siberia.
- The use of Polish became a symbol of national struggle against Russian dominance.
Polish Nationalism through Music and Language
- Poland had been partitioned in the late eighteenth century by Russia, Prussia and Austria.
- Though Poland lost its independence, national feelings were kept alive through music and language.
- Karol Kurpinski promoted national struggle through operas and music.
- Folk dances like the polonaise and mazurka became symbols of nationalism.
Romanticism and Nationalist Sentiment
- Nationalism developed not only through wars and territorial expansion but also through culture.
- Art, poetry, stories and music helped to express and shape nationalist feelings.
- Romanticism was a cultural movement that promoted nationalist sentiment.
- Romantic artists and poets criticised the glorification of reason and science.
- They focused on emotions, intuition and mystical feelings.
- Their aim was to create a sense of shared collective heritage and a common cultural past as the basis of a nation.
- Johann Gottfried Herder believed that true German culture was found among the common people (das volk).
- Folk songs, folk poetry and folk dances expressed the true spirit of the nation (volksgeist).
- Collecting and recording folk culture became important for nation-building.
- Emphasis on vernacular language and folklore helped spread nationalist ideas among illiterate people.
Grimm Brothers and Cultural Nationalism in Germany
- Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm believed French domination threatened German culture.
- They considered folktales as expressions of a pure and authentic German spirit.
- They travelled for six years, gathering stories from villages.
- In 1812, they published their first collection of Grimm’s Fairy Tales.
- They also published a 33-volume dictionary of the German language.
- They later became active in liberal politics, especially supporting freedom of the press.\
The Silesian Weavers’ Revolt (1845)
- In 1845, Silesian weavers revolted against contractors who drastically reduced their wages.
- Journalist Wilhelm Wolff described their extreme poverty and miserable working conditions.
- On 4 June, the weavers marched to the contractor’s house demanding higher wages.
- They were treated with scorn and threats by the contractor.
- The weavers forced their way into the house, smashed window panes, furniture and porcelain.
- They broke into the storehouse and tore the cloth supplies to shreds.
- The contractor fled with his family to a neighbouring village, which refused to shelter him.
- He later returned with the army, and eleven weavers were shot dead.
Economic Hardship and the Revolution of 1848
- The 1830s were marked by severe economic hardship and rapid population growth in Europe.
- Unemployment increased, and many rural people migrated to overcrowded cities.
- Small producers suffered due to competition from cheap machine-made goods from England.
- Peasants faced heavy feudal dues, and rising food prices or bad harvests caused widespread poverty.
- In 1848, food shortages and unemployment led to an uprising in Paris.
- Louis Philippe was forced to flee, and a Republic was proclaimed.
- Universal male suffrage (above 21 years) was granted.
- The right to work was guaranteed.
- National workshops were established to provide employment.
Unification of Germany
- Liberals of German demanded a constitution, freedom of press, freedom of association and a nation-state based on parliamentary principles.
- On 18 May 1848, 831 representatives met at St. Paul’s Church in Frankfurt to form an all-German National Assembly.
- The Frankfurt Parliament drafted a constitution for a German nation under a constitutional monarchy.
- The crown was offered to Frederick William IV, King of Prussia, but he rejected it.
- The monarchy, army and aristocracy opposed the Assembly.
- The Parliament lost support because it ignored the demands of workers and artisans.
- Troops were called and the Assembly was dissolved.
- After 1848, nationalism became associated with conservative state power rather than democracy.
- Prussia took leadership in German unification.
- Otto von Bismarck, the Chief Minister of Prussia, led the unification process with the help of the army and bureaucracy.
- Three wars were fought against Denmark(1864), Austria (1866) and France (1870), leading to Prussian victories.
- In January 1871, William I was proclaimed German Emperor at the Palace of Versailles.
- The new German Empire strengthened and modernised its currency, banking, legal and judicial systems under Prussian dominance.
Comments
Post a Comment